Comment on page

Phase 2: Proposal Refinement & Temperature Check

At this stage, you should ideally have some community interest in the Discord governance channels from Phase 1: Informal Discussion.
It is time to formalize your proposal with a Proposal Draft & discuss the details with the community. We will be using
  • Github Issues in the SWIPs Repository to record your Proposal Drafts, Final Proposals & Temperature Check
  • Discord governance thread to discuss and seek feedback from community
  1. 1.
    Do not skip Phase 1 - start a Discord discussion before creating a SWIP
  2. 2.
    Be constructive
  3. 3.
    Be clear (use data, charts & images)

1. Create a Proposal Draft (Github Issue) in the SWIPS repository

In the SWIPS Github Repository, create an Issue with the title SWIP-n Draft:Proposal Title. See sample Proposal Draft Issue here:
Sample of a Proposal Draft Github Issue
Sample of Proposal Draft discussion on Discord

3. Create Final Proposal with community feedback

After discussing & seeking feedback from the community for 48 hours, you should refine your Proposal Draft into a Final Proposal. Add a comment in your Github issue with the changes. See sample Final Proposal here:
Sample of Final Proposal Github Issue

4. Paste the Final Proposal in Discord with emoji polling

In this step,
  1. 1.
    Paste the Final Proposal link in Discord with the following message: After 48 hours of discussion, this is the Final Proposal for SWIP-n: Github link. For the next 48 hours, we will be doing a temperature check. Please react with
    if you are FOR or AGAINST this proposal respectively.
  2. 2.
    React to your post with
Sample of Discord emoji polling for temperature check

After Discord polling

The Discord poll should have a 60%
approval. If this is achieved,
  1. 1.
    Post a comment in the Github Issue & on Discord with the following format From DD:MM:HH to DD:MM:HH, a Discord poll was conducted for the Final Proposal. Out of <> Members, <> voted for and <> voted against the Proposal. With the above, the Proposal has passed/failed and will/ will not go for Snapshot voting.
  2. 2.
    Add a Markdown file with your Final Proposal content to and create a Pull Request
  3. 3.
    Proceed to Phase 3: Signal Voting. This means that the direction and details of the proposal is generally sound and ready for the community to signal-vote.
Sample of Temperature check results on Github Issues
Sample of Temperature check results on Discord
If you did not receive a 60% approval, you can refine your proposal and start from Phase 2's Step 1 again.